Another Easily Averted Tragedy…

This morning we all woke up to the terrible and shocking news that a shooting instructor (I refuse to call him a Range Master) was shot and killed by a nine year old girl with an Uzi sub-machine gun (SMG).  It is a tragedy on two fronts – of course it is a tragedy for the family and friends of the deceased, for whom I pray.  However as my friend Greg Starks rightly points out, it is also a tragedy for the little girl.

…All the adults involved chose to enter the situation.  The girl – for her this was like being taken to the park to learn to ride a bike… in her mind, was something cool she was doing with Mommy and Daddy… now how F`d up is her life?… just trying not to lose focus from the tragedy of the girl, given that all the adults had the ability and opportunity to make different choices.  Making her a poster child will only propagate how many times people watch her take a human life.

I pray for the nine year old girl, who will carry this tragedy with her for her entire life.  I will not name her, nor will I name the parents (who should, in my opinion, go to jail for manslaughter) because it could then be linked back to the girl.

So who is to blame for this tragedy?  Some will say the parents, and I agree; some will say the range owners, and I agree with them too.  Others will say it is the Second Amendment… and it is hard to disagree that in the larger picture the ‘Right to bear arms’ is apart of it… but above all else I think it is the American glorification of firearms and their use that is really to blame.  After all, guns are legal (albeit regulated a lot more tightly) in Canada.  Heck, in Israel everyone has a firearm as soon as they go into the army, and there is zero gun crime and almost no accidental shootings.  What makes those cultures different from the US?  We don’t glorify them.

Name a Canadian hero or legend who carried a gun.  Maybe you can… if you give it some thought.  Probably not though.  Name an Israeli hero or legend who carried a gun?  There are plenty of course – all of Israel’s heroes are/were soldiers.

Name an American hero who carried a gun? Wyatt Earp; Jesse James; Billy the Kid.  It took me three seconds to come up with three names.  Sure, some of the American heroes will be law men… but they also glorify the villains.

The American Bill of Rights (in which the Second Amendment is codified) were written in 1789.

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Back then there were no handguns, and a rifle (musket) would fire one shot, then take nearly a minute to reload.  Effective range?  Depending on the model probably as far as 50 meters.  In contrast, an Uzi (designed in 1948 but manufactured by Israeli Military Industries since 1954) fires 600 rounds per minute with an effective range of 2200 meters, from a magazine that holds anywhere from 10 to 50 9mm rounds. 

Because of an ingenious piece of material (that is, I was told by my Range Master in Basic Training, made of a secret material) there is hardly any recoil to an Uzi.  This makes it so easy to fire that ‘even a child could do it.’  Our Range Master was of course joking about this, showing that any simple soldier could fire the weapon.  Unfortunately there are people in the USA who took this literally, and thought that a nine year old child could and should be allowed to fire it.

Someone paid with their life.  The poor child will be scarred forever.  And gun enthusiasts and members of the NRA all over America are going to dismiss this as an unfortunate incident caused by poor training.  I weep for the USA.


5 responses to “Another Easily Averted Tragedy…”

  1. This incident was undoubtedly preventable by the parents & the clearly incompetent “instructor”. But, you might need to review the facts regarding the availability of repeating action firearms around the days of the American Revolution. There’s a few links in this discussion:

    Don’t fall for the “Founding Fathers couldn’t have envisioned…” which the US Anti-Constitution activist fall for w/the 2A, but seem to forget all about w/the 1A & freedom of the press.

    I do agree that “glorifying” lethal force is a problem w/American popular culture.

  2. “zero gun crime” Where are you getting these stats? Because here: it details in 2011 there was a total of 157 gun deaths; 81 considered “homicide” (although a fantastic rate compared to USA). Although, only 4 were “unintentional”, so I would call that “almost no accidental shootings” too. I don’t believe the gun policy has changed (“everyone has a firearm”) in the following two years, so I don’t think the stats should be that much different for 2013.

    1. Peter my statistics are anecdotal and outdated… but a great number of those are likely terrorist related as well… not excusing it.

  3. I couldn’t find anything that mentioned no terrorism, so I don’t know…

  4. Dudley Do-Right Mountie
    But on a serious note, when one is instructing a child or excited person. You should never have more then 1 (one) round in the gun, then 2(two) then 3 (Three) before loading a full magazine.
    When the 2nd amendment was written , The smooth bore musket was the “”ASSAULT Weapon”” of the time.
    Riffled barrels where considered weapons of terror.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: