Start here

Server Core: Every bit the Full Server as the GUI is!

Microsoft introduced Server Core with Windows Server 2008, which means that it was the same kernel as Windows Vista.  Now, nobody is going to stand up and sing the praises of Vista, but Server 2008 was a very solid OS.

You may (or may not) remember that there was a campaign around Vista called ‘The WOW starts NOW!’ Catchy, huh?  Well, because Server Core was literally taking the ‘bling’ out of Windows Server, there was an internal joke at the time that ‘The Wow STOPS Now.’

While Server Core never looked very exciting for end users, for IT Admins, and especially those who were building virtualized environments, Server Core was a godsend. Let’s go through this one more time to demonstrate why:

  • The Windows Graphical User Interface (GUI), which is the difference between Server Core and not, takes resources.  How much?  Well, depending on the server it might be as much as 3-4GB on the hard drive and as much as 350MB of RAM.  Neither of these is a big deal in a world where servers have 128GB of RAM and terabytes of storage on them, right?  Well on a virtualization host that may have on average 100 virtual machines running simultaneously, that translates to 400GB of storage and a ridiculous 35GB of RAM… Ouch.
  • Every component that is installed in Windows has to be patched from time to time.  The fewer components you have installed, the less patching that has to be done.
  • The more you have installed in Windows the larger your attach surface.  By removing components, you can minimize this, making your computer more secure.

servercore01In Windows Server 2008 here’s what we saw when we initiated the installation… a menu with all three editions (Standard, Enterprise, Datacenter) Full Installation, and the three editions with Server Core Installation.

I have been singing the praises of Server Core for as long as it has been available, but often to deaf ears.  I always assumed this was because most IT Admins liked the GUI.  Recently I was in a presentation given by Jeffrey Snover, who gave me another perspective on it… the terminology in Server 2008 was part of it.  You see, people look at the options ‘Full Server’ versus ‘Server Core’ and they immediately think ‘power & performance.’ A Full Server must do more than a server core server… why?  It is FULL!

Of course, in Server 2008 it didn’t help that Server Core actually was a hobbled version of Server… there were a few roles that worked on it, but not too many.

As with so many Microsoft products, that got better in 2008 R2, and even better in Server 2012 and 2012 R2.  Today you would be amazed at what can run on Server Core… in fact, nearly everything that you do on a server can run on Server Core.  So there is little wonder that Microsoft made a change to the terms…

servercore02No longer is it a question of FULL versus CORE… Now our options are Server Core Installation and Server with a GUI.

There are two differences to notice in this screen shot… the first is that there are only four options because Microsoft eliminated the Enterprise SKU.  The second is that the default option (a la next – next – next installations) is Server Core.  While some admins might say ‘Yeah I wasn’t paying attention so I ended up with Server Core and had to reinstall,’ the reality is that most of us, once we understand the benefits and the manageability options, will want to install Server Core instead of the GUI servers.

Of course, there are admins who will still be afraid of the command line… but because most of the ongoing administration of our servers (the things we usually do with MMC consoles) Server Core, or at the very least MinShell will make our lives easier.  MinShell removes most of the GUI, but leaves the MMC consoles.

But what if I wanted to use the GUI to configure the system, and then get rid of it completely?  We can definitely do that.  One method of doing it is to use the Server Manager’s Remove Roles and Features option.  (The GUI is a feature, and is listed under User Interfaces and Infrastructure – Server Graphical Shell)  This will uninstall the components and save the RAM… but it will not free up your hard disk space.  To do that, use the following PowerShell cmdlet:

Uninstall-WindowsFeature –Name Server-Gui-Mgmt-Infra,Server-Gui-Shell –ComputerName <Name> -Remove -Restart

The -ComputerName option allows you to do this to remote computers, and the -Remove option actually removes the bits from the hard drive.

What can you do with Server Core? I won’t say everything… but nearly so.  It is no longer just your Hyper-V hosts… it is your domain controllers, SQL Servers, Web Servers, and so much more.  As long as you are able to learn a little bit of PowerShell… and how to enable remote management on your servers.

Now go forward and save your resources!

We love the device… the only complaint we have is that the battery doesn’t last very long.

That quote is from Theresa, and the device she is referring to is her new HP Stream 7 that I picked up for her and our younger son (see article).  I was surprised, because the promotional material for the Stream boasts up to 8 hours of battery.  I was also getting more than enough from mine… I unplugged it in the morning, watched videos on the train on my way to the office, and then again on the train on the way home.  I plugged it back in, and poof, the day was done.


One day, however, I used the device during the day.  My regular lunch companions were in a meeting, so I watched a video at lunch.  Knowing that I was doing this, I started downloading another video to watch on the train.  When I was finished with my lunch I closed the cover (as I do to put my Surface Pro to sleep) and put it aside.  When I got onto the train home I tried to boot it up to watch my videos, and the battery was dead.


Okay, there are a few things you need to know about the Stream.  The first is that, unlike the Surface Pro, it is a pure tablet device and not a hybrid.  Whereas the type cover to the Surface is actually connected electronically to the device so it senses that it is closed, the cover for the HP is just a cover.  The second thing is that, like every other computer in the world, the more it is doing, the shorter the battery life will be.  So the action of downloading the new video (which I usually do when it is plugged in at home), coupled with the fact that the tablet was on all afternoon, drained the battery.

So what can I do to conserve my device’s battery?  Here are a few tips.

While I am writing it specifically about the HP Stream, the following tips will work to extend the battery life of any portable computer.

  1. Choose the power plan that is best for you.  A lot of people think they need full power all the time on their device, and it is possible that you do.  However Windows has several Power Plans that you can use to conserve power, and you can access these by clicking on the battery icon in the task bar.  These power plans include different settings for ‘On battery’ versus ‘Plugged in’, so when I am at home downloading my videos, I can set the download working and walk away without worrying that my tablet will go to sleep and interrupt the download.  However when it is NOT plugged in, I now have the ‘Put the computer to sleep’ option set to 4 minutes, so I won’t close the cover and drain the battery.
  2. Lower the brightness.  This is part of the power plan as well, but is also easy to adjust.  On a bright sunny day on the train I do need the screen to be brighter, but I have to remember that the brighter it is, the more battery it consumes.  Lower the brightness when you don’t need it.
  3. Turn off what you don’t need!  Most devices these days have Bluetooth and WiFi built in, and that is great… but they also consume resources.  If you don’t need the Bluetooth on a regular basis, turn it off.  However Windows includes a great ‘catch-all’ for transmitting and receiving functions… Enabling Airplane Mode disables them all with one button, and then re-enables them when you disable it.  in Windows 8 swipe from the right, click Settings, click on the network option (this may be renamed after your wireless network) and switch it on.
  4. Processes running in the background consume resources.  Open your Task Manager and see what is running… and then turn off what you don’t need.

None of these tips are really all that new, but since the concept of using a device all day without plugging it in probably is to most of us, following these simple tips can help extend the life of your battery.  There are probably many more which I haven’t mentioned… I would love for you to put them in to the Comments section!

Where am I? HELP!

My colleague created a virtual machine for me in our datacentre a few weeks ago.  (Thanks Michael!)  Earlier this week I needed to create a second virtual machine to cluster with it, and I felt that the best way to maximize my resources completely would be to create another virtual machine identical to the first.  Okay, all I had to do was pop open the Settings window for the virtual machine and copy it.

We have 25 physical host servers in the lab environment in question, and no Virtual Machine Manager.  Crap.

I could, if I had to, connect to each host one by one looking for the virtual machine in question, but that would be a waste of time… not to mention that as a one-off solution it could work, but it is a bad habit to get into.  I needed a better solution.

If you ever find yourself in the position, here’s a tip: As long as you have the Integration Services installed, there is a registry key in the virtual machine that gives me my answer.  So open Regedit and navigate to:

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Virtual Machine\Guest\Parameters

See? There it is, right there in black and white.  In fact, it’s there three times – under HostName, PhysicalHostName, and PhysicalHostNameFullyQualified.   I no longer need a map, I no longer need to go looking by hand.

But Mitch, isn’t there a way to do this in PowerShell?

I’m glad you asked.  Sure, here it is:

(Get-ItemProperty –path “HKLM:\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Virtual Machine\Guest\Parameters”).PhysicalHostName

Of course, if you are a stickler about it, you can change the last bit to PhysicalHostNameFullyQualified, but that’s up to you.

Now that you know where you are… keep going!

Step by Step: Building a Scale-Out File Server (SoFS) on Windows Server 2012 R2

In several presentations since Windows Server 2012 was released I have heard Microsofties claim that SAN devices are a thing of the past.  I have a hard time getting on board with that, but have nonetheless told many an audience that if they are planning on throwing their SANs out because Microsoft said so then just let me know where they are doing it so I can come collect them.

That is not to say that Windows Server 2012 (and since 2012 R2) have not changed the storage game significantly.  I have lectured extensively on Storage Pools (also known as Storage Spaces), and Cluster Shared Volumes are huge.

However since the world is going virtual, perhaps the most important storage use right now is the storage of virtual machines… and if I may borrow the motto of the Olympic Games, the order of this era of computing is “Citius, Atius, Fortius…” or Faster, Higher, Stronger. The storage on which we trust our virtual machines must be faster than ever, with higher availability than ever, and more resilient than ever.  In short, we are trying to deliver perfection… just like an Olympian.

So how are we going to architect our Olympian storage solution for our virtual machines?

Scale-Out File Servers (SoFS).

SoFS is a redundant, Actove/Active clustered file server based on SMB (Server Message Block) 3.0.  You aren’t going to build an SoFS cluster for your normal file servers – there are plenty of great technologies available for that, ranging from DFS-R to Clustered File Servers.  Rather, SoFS is designed for high usage, always-open files, like virtual machines and SQL Servers.


If you are building this out in a lab you can get away with less, but in my experience you need a cluster that is separate from your Hyper-V cluster.  I also prefer building my SoFS on physical hardware rather than on virtual, but this is negotiable.

To get started you have to make sure you have storage that can be added to a Failover Cluster.  This can be done with Storage Pools, but I’ll do it with virtual disks.

Step 1: Build your Failover Cluster. I have already written about how to build a Failover Cluster.  Follow Steps 1 & 2 in this article and you will be good to go.  You can even go through the observational components of Step 3 that will verify quorum and things like that, but do not do the storage pars.

Step 2: Configure Storage.

This is the part that got me tripped up the first few times I tried to get it to work, and that was mostly because I didn’t RTFM.  However in my defense, a lot of what tripped me up initially was not spelled out to clearly in the reading material.

In order for disks to be added to the cluster, they must be shared by all of the nodes of the cluster.  If you are building a Software SAN on Windows Server 2012 R2 you can follow the instructions in this article.  Finding the SAN LUNs from Windows Server just requires the iSCSI Initiator.  Ensure that all nodes of your cluster are connected.

Incidentally having the shared storage may be enough to add it to your cluster, but in order to make this work the LUNs have to have a formatted partition on them.  This was one of the gotchas I discovered along the way.

**VERY IMPORTANT NOTE:  If your storage is ready to go when you create the cluster then you are fine, but remember that any time you make changes to your cluster you need to re-run the Validation Tests.  As long as these tests are run and come back as ‘Suitable for Clustering’ then you are fine, but if they do not then Microsoft will not support you in your time of need.

So in Failover Cluster Manager if you expand <Cluster Name> – Storage – Disks you should see in the main window a list of all of your drives.


In this screenshot we see that the disk we want to use (Cluster Disk 5) is assigned to Available Storage.  That is the disk we are going to use.  Right-click on it, and click Add to Cluster Shared Volumes.

A Note about Cluster Shared Volumes (CSVs)

A Cluster Shared Volume is a pointer.  It takes my LUN and puts it on my C Drive… okay, not really.  However if I want to access my LUN from my server, I could refer to it as, or I can assign it a drive letter.

The problem with assigning it a drive letter is that in a failover cluster there are multiple nodes that need to access the same LUN, and since drive letters are assigned by the server and not by the cluster, in order to ensure proper functionality I would have to ensure that each LUN had the same drive letter across all nodes in my cluster… which is simple, as long as the storage configuration (including hard drives & partitions, RAID arrays, CD/DVDs, and yes even USB keys) across all nodes in the cluster are identical.  If not, then it’s a hassle.

What CSVs do for me is takes the hassle out, and assigns a pointer to each LUN on my C drive… under c:\Cluster Storage\ each CSV will have its own directory, which is really a portal to my LUN.  So the one we created in the previous step is called c:\Cluster Storage\Volume 2.


**IMPORTANT NOTE: While it may work, do not use your CSVs for anything other than Hyper-V and Failover Clusters.  It will bite you eventually, and hard.

So now that I have my storage in place, let’s go ahead and build our Scale-Out File Server.

Step 3: Creating the Scale-Out File Server

SoFS is clustered role.

1. In the Navigation Pane of Failover Cluster Manager right-click Roles and click Configure Role…

2. In the Before You Begin page read the notes and click Next.

3. In the Select Role page select File Server and click Next.

4. In the File Server Type page click the radio Scale-Out File Server for application data and click Next.  Note the warnings that SoFS does not support the NFS Protocol, DFS Replicastion, or File Server Resource Manager.

5. In the Client Access Point page type a name for your SoFS and click Next.  Note that the name must be NetBIOS compliant.

6. On the Confirmation page ensure your information is correct and click Next

When you are done click Close and then navigate to Roles.  You should see your role all ready.


Step 4: Creating a File Share

This is where all of the steps we went through before are important… you can only create a File Share for your SoFS on high availability storage.

1. Right-click on your SoFS role and click Add File Share. (If you get an error see this article, wait, then try again in a few minutes.

2. In the Select the profile for this share window select SMB Share – Applications and click Next.

3. In the Select the server and path for this share window select the your SoFS by name under the list of servers.  Ensure the radio Select by volume is selected.  Select the disk you want to create it on, and then click Next.

**NOTE: Notice that the volumes available are actually your CSVs, and that the File System listed is CSVFS.

4. In the Specify share name window type the name of your share, along with any notes you wish.  Note that the remote path to the share will be \\SoFSName\ShareName.  Click Next.

5. In the Configure Share settings window notice that several options are greyed out, including the Enable continuous availability option, which is forced.  Your only choice here is whether to Encrypt data access, which you can do for security.  Click Next.

6. In the Specify permissions to control access window you can modify the permissions, but remember that it is the Hyper-V hosts that will need access.  Click Next.

7. On the Confirm selections page ensure your settings are correct, then click Create.


8. On the View results page ensure all steps are marked Completed, then click Close.

We’re done… Your Scale-Out File Server is ready to go.  All you have to do is start migrating your VMs from where they were to (in this case) \\ServerName\PDisks. You can click on your role, and at the bottom of the screen select the Shares tab, and there it is… or in the case of this system, there they are, because yes, you can have multiple file shares on a single SoFS role.

Caveat Admin

Microsoft and Hyper-V, along with a lot of guidance from people like the author, have made virtualization available to anyone.  With Failover Clusters they have made high availability easier than ever.  However Icarus please remember that the solid foundation on which these tools are built depend on the integrity of your waxen wings; just because you are able to create something does not mean you have the knowledge of how to maintain it.  If you don’t believe me, go ask any single mother with a dead-beat absent father.  The fact that Windows Server 2012R2 makes these tasks so easy to do does not change the fact that this is still 400 level stuff, and proper education and certifications are always recommended before you bite off more than you can chew.  All of the resources you need are available, you just have to look for them.  Start at, and go from there.

Help! Where is my Client Access Point?

So you are building a Scale Out File Server (SoFS).  You are all happy because you read one of my articles (or POSSIBLY someone else’s… but really, why would you hurt me like that?) and you know you are good to go.  You have your cluster, you have your drives, and you have created your SoFS role.  Now all that’s left to do is to add a file share to the role.


Huh?  What did you do wrong?

Relax… you didn’t do anything wrong.  When you create the SoFS role in Failover Cluster Manager, it will take some time to propagate the namespace throughout Active Directory.  How long? UCA.  However depending on how large your network topology is, it can take a little time.  Just go for lunch, a smoke, maybe get out and stretch your legs, go for a jog… when you come back you should be ready to go!

Stream-lining: A review of my new companion device.

I have always had a deal with the companies that have supported me over the years: If you give me a product to test and I like it, I will write about it. If I don’t like it, I will not write about it. That is why there are so few negative reviews on my site. It has always been a workable arrangement that has allowed me to showcase positive technologies for them. There are plenty of sites out there who are all too happy to write the negatives.

I say this because three years ago my friends at HP gave me a device that I did not like. To date I think it is the only HP device that they have given me that I did not like, and I never wrote about it. It was a tablet device that I think was still running Windows 7. It was just not my cup of tea.

So when my friends at the Microsoft Store showed me a new 7” HP tablet a few weeks ago I was hesitant. I know, it runs Windows 8.1, and only weighs a little less than a pound… but would I really use it? I mean, I have a Surface Pro 3 as my corporate device, and another Surface Pro 3 for my personal stuff, and between the two of them I am more than covered. I was afraid the ship had likely sailed on my becoming enamoured with HP tablets.

Enter my son.

No, not Aaron. My 17 year old has a Surface RT as a companion device to his HP EliteBook laptop. He treats them both with the respect that his mother and I have taught him.

Gilad, on the other hand, is an entirely different story. Our 5 year old is a rambunctious little guy, and it is not hard to see that he is his father’s son. For those of you who know me when I was much younger, that is a very scary thought. He has the temper and the attitude and the tantrums and the lack of control that he comes by honestly. Only when I was of that age, home computers did not get dropped… because they had not been invented yet, and when they did come around they were expensive and heavy and cumbersome. In this day and age where almost all computers are portable and tablet computers weigh a pound, it is easy to forget that they break. Add to that games which require the player to hold the tablet up to steer, and the dangers are real.

“Mitch, Gilad dropped the Surface one too many times last week, and the screen broke and it is now unusable.”

The fact that it took as long as it did for me to hear that was a bit surprising, but that is that call I got last week. My mind immediately went to the $99 HP Stream 7 that my friend showed me, and I promised Theresa that I would pick one up for her, and that is what I did on Wednesday. I spent the extra money on the screen protector and case/stand, and it cost me, all told, $150.

Stream 7

Over the next few days I gave it a lot of thought… I commute into Toronto 4 days a week, spending nearly an hour on the train each way. What I have been doing is downloading my TV shows onto my personal Surface Pro, and I would watch them on the train. It is a great solution, but it also means I am carrying a $1500 tablet around. Yes, it has the Complete Care warranty in case I drop it, but what if it gets stolen? I decided that for what I do on the train, I was going to take the plunge.

I picked up the HP Stream 7 on Monday. I got the same package as I had bought for Theresa, except in lieu of her light blue cover I opted for the black. I was ambivalent because it only had 32gb of storage, 1gb of RAM, and an ATOM processor… but even with that it runs the full Windows (not Windows RT), and for what I need it for, that should really be enough. In fact, it might be considered overkill J

Two Ports, Three Buttons.

Stream 7 CornerI believe in the KISS principle… but I cannot think of any device I have ever owned that had less to it: a micro-USB port (which, from what I can tell, is only meant to charge the device) and a headset port (which was not a deal breaker, since otherwise I would have bought Bluetooth headphones); it has a power button, an up-volume and a down-volume button… and that’s it. I did not think it possible to have a fully functional device with less buttons than my iPhone, but there is was. Okay, I suppose the Windows logo could be considered a button, so it is actually tied with the iPhone. No matter, it works.

The first problem I encountered was file transmission speed… traditionally I download my TV shows on my Surface Pro (the personal one, in case anyone at Rakuten is reading this). For the first few days I would then transfer them to the HP. Unfortunately transferring a low-res one-hour TV show over wifi seemed to take a long time… 8 minutes. Wow, there has to be a better way…

…and there it was! In a very under-promoted feat of innovation, if you pop the back cover off the device with your fingernail, there is a Micro-SD card slot! Woohoo! Increased storage, here I come!

Stream 7 BackThen it occurred to me… why take all of these extra (and probably unnecessary) steps? I will now just download my shows onto the tablet, and skip the middle-man (not to mention free up my SP3 for more important duties).

I went looking for other problems… but so far I haven’t found any. There’s no external display port. Who cares, it’s a companion device! It doesn’t have a USB port. Who cares, it’s a companion device! There’s no stylus, and if you want to attach a mouse or keyboard you have to do it over Bluetooth. Who the heck cares, it’s a companion device!

So let’s review… For $99 (plus the cost of the screen protector and case) I picked up a tablet with 32gb of storage that is expandable to 160gb, has a gigabyte of RAM, runs all of my applications that I need, has front and rear-facing cameras, and fits in my back pocket, lets me watch movies and listen to music on the go, and Oh, by the way, for the price also comes with a year subscription to Microsoft Office 365, AND came with a $25 voucher for the Windows Store. Add to that the Bitlocker encryption on the hard drive, and a 5-point touch screen, and this device that actually does fit into my back pocket is a better computer than my first laptop… and probably my second and third one now that I think of it…

I should mention that it is now the only device I have that runs the 32-bit version of Windows. Who cares, it’s a companion device! I keep saying that because really, it does everything I need. I wouldn’t replace my primary systems with it, and I wouldn’t dream of trying to run Photoshop on it. But for years I have talked about The Best Tool for the Job, and for what I will be using it for, the HP Stream 7 really does seem to be that.

Of course, it does run Windows, so I will be adding it to my Windows Intune account for anti-malware and management. Intune has never led me astray, so the fact that it is able to manage my tablet without mucking about with APNS Certificates made my life easier.

Earlier this week I was sitting in the lunch room on my break, watching a movie. Someone came up and asked me about the device, and of course I showed him my new toy. He then asked me ‘So why did you pick this and not an iPad?’ I had a few answers for him… yes, I used to be a Microsoftie, and yes, I am a big fan of Windows 8.1, and of course I know the OS much better than I know iOS… but the bottom line is that the least expensive iPad costs about $300; that is not unreasonable, but it is also not an impulse purchase. At $99 the HP Stream 7 was exactly that; I was at the Microsoft Store for another reason, I looked at it, and I decided to buy it. I had not walked in with the intention of walking out with one, but there it was. It costs one third what the iPad would cost me, and the only thing that I know of that it does not do is Facetime. Fortunately the entire world also has Skype, so I won’t really suffer.

Let me be clear: This is not simply a rewired and rebranded HP Slate 2. This is a spectacular and fully functional device that is not trying to be all things to all people, but instead does what it is meant to do really well.

Overall, it gets a huge thumbs up from this user… and unlike many of the devices I have discussed in the past I paid full boat for this. Nonetheless, thanks HP!

My New Word…?

I was driving with a friend over the week-end, and describing the behaviour of someone with whom I recently cut all ties.  Part of the reason I did is because she is a master manipulator.  “She is a Manipulatrix.”

Brad said he loved that word, even though he had never heard it before.  I admit, I hadn’t either… we thought that I had coined a new word.

When I looked it up on-line before claiming the credit for it, unfortunately there was not only a definition on Urban Dictionary- Manipulatrix, there is even a site (which claims on the first screen to be “NOT FOR THE MEEK!”  So obviously, there is, within the world of alternative sexual lifestyles, previous uses and claims to the word.

With that being said, there is nothing sexual or alternative to the family member to whom I was referring, so I am coining the term thusly:

Manipulatrix: A woman who will manipulate every situation to her advantage, often using detrimental or derogatory actions to belittle the target of her manipulation.

A woman who, using her own wiles, causes others to do her bidding and/or to change situations to her favour.

Let me be clear, before anyone gets any silly ideas: I am not referring to any woman to whom I have dated or been married.  While my marriage to Theresa has ended, we are on very good terms, and I do not consider her in any negative terms.  My first wife may have been a lot of things, but she was not a manipulatrix.


%d bloggers like this: